Hitting cleanup is not something you normally associate with second baseman but it does occur and with Robinson Cano it has taken place 12 times and the Yankees have won 11 of those games. The Yankees are 12-0 without Rodriguez and 11-1 with Cano batting cleanup. Rodriguez had a day off May 2 and Nick Swisher filled in then, but you get the idea about how well Cano has been playing as a cleanup hitter and his MVP chances.
Here’s a sampling of active second baseman who have batted there this year and in their careers:
Dan Uggla 37 games .318 (43-for-135) with 14 home runs, 31 RBI, did it four times before this season.
Brandon Phillips 22 games .239 (21-for-88) with three home runs, 10 RBI and a .285 OBP, never batted cleanup before this year
Chase Utley’s career numbers there are .271 (29-for-107) with five home runs and 19 RBI
Dustin Pedroia’s career numbers there are 13-for-20 with two home runs and seven RBI in six games.
Aaron Hill’s career numbers there are 3-for-13 in six games. He went 1-for-5 in one game this season as a cleanup hitter.
As you can see, does not happen with great frequency even with some of the Hall of Fame second baseman.
Rod Carew: 14 games, 15-for-37 with four RBI
Bobby Doerr 211 games, .281 (229-for-815) with 25 home runs and 158 RBI
Frankie Frisch 139 games, .277 (155-for-559) with 11 home runs and 111 RBI
Charlie Gehringer 171 games, .334 (218-for-653) with 15 home runs and 134 RBI
Billy Herman 38 games, .275 (39-for-142) with 0 home runs and 14 RBI
Rogers Hornsby 1527 games .367 (967-for-2636), 97 home runs, 527 RBI
Tony Lazzeri 102 games, .335, 9, 93
Bill Mazeroski 76 games, .248, seven home runs, 35 RBI
Joe Morgan 51 games, .248, two home runs, 17 RBI
Jackie Robinson 683 games, .329, 79 home runs, 439 RBI*also played 247 games at third, 147 in left field (156 games at fourth in 1949), (137 games, 1950), (136 1951), (34 1952) (114, 1953), (those were his primary second base years).
Ryne Sandberg 137 games, .270, 17 home runs, 72 RBI
So does that mean Cano has a future as a cleanup hitter?
On other teams players on pace for 33 home runs and 112 RBI would definitely have a place there but as long as Alex Rodriguez is healthy, the cleanup spot is his.
The plus side is that assuming Cano does reasonably well, though .375 might be too high of an expectation in the cleanup spot, at least the Yankees know who the replacement will be when Rodriguez is nicked up or just needs a day.
What bears watching is how Cano will do hitting cleanup since the competition level is about to improve slightly with the Blue Jays, White Sox and Athletics. In Cano’s 11 games hitting cleanup that the Yankees have won when Rodriguez has been hurt or getting a day he has faced the following starting pitchers:
1 – 5/28 vs. Cleveland Fausto Carmona, 3-for-4 with a grand slam off Tony Sipp saw 19 pitches and hit a first-pitch grand slam (slider, same location as French
2 – 6/11 vs. Houston Brett Myers 1-for-4, 14 pitches
3 – 6/12 vs. Houston Wandy Rodriguez, 9 pitches 1-for-3,
4 – 6/13 vs. Houston Brian Moehler 1-for-3, home run (on the first pitch), 27 pitches
5 – 6/15 vs. Philadelphia Roy Halladay, 1-for-5, seven pitches
6 – 8/7 vs. Boston John Lackey 2-for-3, 14 pitches
7 – 8/17 vs. Detroit Justin Verlander 1-for-4, home run 20 pitches
8 – 8/18 vs. Detroit Jeremy Bonderman 1-for-3 home run 16 pitches
9 – 8/19 vs. Detroit Rick Porcello 3-for-5, home run, three RBI, 17
10 – 8/21 vs. Seattle Jason Vargas, 2-for-4, 2 RBI, 14 pitches
11 – 8/22 vs. Seattle Luke French 2-for-5, six RBI home run grand slam, 20 pitches
And for comparison to see Cano's improvement in various areas, here are his numbers through August 22 in each of the last four seasons.
2010 – .325, 25 home runs, 86 RBI, OBP. 387, OPS .953, BB 45, SO 58
2009 -- .314, 18 home runs, 61 RBI, .333 OBP, .756 OPS, 23 BB, 44 SO
2008 -- .263, 11 home runs, 56 RBI, .303 OBP, .700 OPS, 24 BB, 44 SO
2007 --. 306, 13 home runs, 71 RBI, .350 OBP, .784 OPS, 32 BB, 68 SO
These numbers are fairly consistent with the exception of 2008 which is Cano’s well-documented down year. The items that really stand out are the rise in on-base percentage, OPS and the jump in walks. Cano’s 45 puts him on pace for 59 which would be his most on any level of pro ball.