if i had to pick one from each season...
season 1 - christa (she had no competition though lol)
season 2 - tiffany
season 3 - brenda
Season 1: Dave was the prettiest by far Season 2: Tiffany was fun
Season 3: Come on--Brenda rocks! Sure Shelly was tough but Are we even sure that She was a really girl?
Season 4: can't wait!!!