Jump Menu:
Post Reply
Page 1 of 6  •  1 2 3 4 5 6 Next
First half report card
4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:12PM #1
luvdayanks
Posts: 20,417
IMO

CC    C
Pettite C-
Kuroda B+
Hughes C-
Phelps B
Logan B
Kelly A-
Claiborne  B
Warren  B
Joba  D
Nova C+
Robertson A
Mo A
Nuno B-
Cano B+
Overbay B
Nix C+
Nunez D
Romine F
Stewart B
Hafner D
Wells C-
Ichiro B
Gardner B

The rest, Youk, Gonzalez, Cruz and the rest of the band aids D-
4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:17PM #2
northernclipper
Posts: 2,315

Sounds about right, but you forgot Joe G.  I'd give him an A-, given the situation he was put in.  nc 

4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:24PM #3
luvdayanks
Posts: 20,417

Jul 14, 2013 -- 9:17PM, northernclipper wrote:


Sounds about right, but you forgot Joe G.  I'd give him an A-, given the situation he was put in.  nc 




Yes, I did nc and that's what I would give him also, A-.

4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:27PM #4
RobS44
Posts: 4,426

Jul 14, 2013 -- 9:17PM, northernclipper wrote:


Sounds about right, but you forgot Joe G.  I'd give him an A-, given the situation he was put in.  nc 





The Girardi haters will disagree, but he really has done quite a job keeping this mess at least technically on contention.


I'd also give the front office an F, though they will have to divide it up behind closed doors since none of us really knows who makes what decisions.

4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:28PM #5
Marvin
Posts: 1,127

I'd probably give Ichiro a higher grade but the others are about right.

4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:30PM #6
Yes36223
Posts: 772

Jul 14, 2013 -- 9:12PM, luvdayanks wrote:

IMO

CC    C
Pettite C-
Kuroda B+ A+
Hughes C-
Phelps B
Logan B
Kelly A-
Claiborne  B
Warren  B
Joba  D
Nova C+
Robertson A
Mo A   A+
Nuno B-
Cano B+
Overbay B
Nix C+
Nunez D D-
Romine F
Stewart B C
Hafner D  F
Wells C-
Ichiro B
Gardner B

The rest, Youk, Gonzalez, Cruz and the rest of the band aids D-




Agreed w/most of what you listed. I gave Mo an A+ since he still performing at very high level at 43 years old. He's outperformimg others half his age.


I gave Hiro an A+ as well as he lost games by 1 run where he pitched his ass off.


Hafner an F as he's paid to do one job & his performance in that 1 job is putrid.


Nunez I felt at the beginning of the season would have hit better. He needs to have an offensive game that makes one forget that he is a defensive liability.


I may be too harsh of a grader on Stewart as he's a career back-up & so he's giving what he's got.

4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:37PM #7
RobS44
Posts: 4,426

Jul 14, 2013 -- 9:12PM, luvdayanks wrote:

IMO

CC    C  A "C" strictly on performance, a "D" based on return on dollars of salary.
Pettite C-
Kuroda B+
Hughes C-
Phelps B
Logan B
Kelly A-
Claiborne  B  B so far, but there are worrisome signs.
Warren  B
Joba  D
Nova C+ Overall a C+ but he HAS looked better in his recent starts (small sample warning)
Robertson A
Mo A
Nuno B-
Cano B+
Overbay B
Nix C+
Nunez D
Romine F
Stewart B
Hafner D
Wells C-
Ichiro B
Gardner B

The rest, Youk, Gonzalez, Cruz and the rest of the band aids D-




4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 9:41PM #8
78Bombers
Posts: 2,823

Jul 14, 2013 -- 9:12PM, luvdayanks wrote:

IMO

CC    C
Pettite C-
Kuroda B+
Hughes C-
Phelps B
Logan B
Kelly A-
Claiborne  B
Warren  B
Joba  D
Nova C+
Robertson A
Mo A
Nuno B-
Cano B+
Overbay B
Nix C+
Nunez D
Romine F
Stewart B
Hafner D
Wells C-
Ichiro B
Gardner B

The rest, Youk, Gonzalez, Cruz and the rest of the band aids D-



Agree with most of your grades...


Joba gets an F ... you can't really pitch him anymore...it looks like his Yankee career may be coming to an end...F for Failure.


Hafner gets a C-... some production despite low ba...he managed to avoid catastrophic injury and that's a plus for TH.

4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 10:08PM #9
YankeeLoon
Posts: 17,903
I agree with all of these luv, but Kuroda, Mo get half grade higher and Stewart and Phelps a half grade lower.
4 years ago  ::  Jul 14, 2013 - 11:51PM #10
ArtVandelay
Posts: 24,898

Hank.  A+

Page 1 of 6  •  1 2 3 4 5 6 Next
Jump Menu:
 
    Viewing this thread :: 0 registered and 1 guest
    No registered users viewing

Yankees Forum