Jump Menu:
Post Reply
Page 1 of 8  •  1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 8 Next
Who wants Gardner back???
4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 1:01PM #1
Raymond757
Posts: 9,418
Ok, here is your chance to express your opinion...
Mine is one year.
4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 1:43PM #2
GottaGoToMo
Posts: 77,711

One last year ... Hicks won't be around anyway.

4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 1:49PM #3
manbot
Posts: 607

No ... unless they can get rid of Stanton ...then Yes 1 year 

  • RF - Judge /  Andujar 
  • LF - Stanton / Frazier / Wade 
  • CF - Tauchman /Hicks / Ellsbury   

DH - Stanton, Voit, Ford, Andujar


That's 8 potential OFers without Gardner why pay $7-10M when it could be used for a starting Pitcher, Betances, Romine  or anothe rBU cathcer.


There's just no room for this uneceesary glut of OFers and DHs


4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 1:54PM #4
luvdayanks
Posts: 27,262

Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:49PM, manbot wrote:


No ... unless they can get rid of Stanton ...then Yes 1 year 

  • RF - Judge /  Andujar 
  • LF - Stanton / Frazier / Wade 
  • CF - Tauchman /Hicks / Ellsbury   

DH - Stanton, Voit, Ford, Andujar


That's 8 potential OFers without Gardner why pay $7-10M when it could be used for a starting Pitcher, Betances, Romine  or anothe rBU cathcer.


There's just no room for this uneceesary glut of OFers and DHs





Surely you're  not  serious  putting  Hicks and Ellsbury on that list. Hicks will be out for a good part of  the  year and Ellsbury isn't  even a remote possibility of playing next season. Even if he did, do you really  think he's  going to do anything having  been out 2 years and fragile  as a snowflake???

4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 1:55PM #5
GottaGoToMo
Posts: 77,711

Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:54PM, luvdayanks wrote:


Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:49PM, manbot wrote:


No ... unless they can get rid of Stanton ...then Yes 1 year 

  • RF - Judge /  Andujar 
  • LF - Stanton / Frazier / Wade 
  • CF - Tauchman /Hicks / Ellsbury   

DH - Stanton, Voit, Ford, Andujar


That's 8 potential OFers without Gardner why pay $7-10M when it could be used for a starting Pitcher, Betances, Romine  or anothe rBU cathcer.


There's just no room for this uneceesary glut of OFers and DHs





Surely you're  not  serious  putting  Hicks and Ellsbury on that list. Hicks will be out for a good part of  the  year and Ellsbury isn't  even a remote possibility of playing next season. Even if he did, do you really  think he's  going to do anything having  been out 2 years and fragile  as a snowflake???




Actually I can't stop laughing at putting Andujar in right field.

4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 1:59PM #6
luvdayanks
Posts: 27,262

Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:55PM, GottaGoToMo wrote:


Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:54PM, luvdayanks wrote:


Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:49PM, manbot wrote:


No ... unless they can get rid of Stanton ...then Yes 1 year 

  • RF - Judge /  Andujar 
  • LF - Stanton / Frazier / Wade 
  • CF - Tauchman /Hicks / Ellsbury   

DH - Stanton, Voit, Ford, Andujar


That's 8 potential OFers without Gardner why pay $7-10M when it could be used for a starting Pitcher, Betances, Romine  or anothe rBU cathcer.


There's just no room for this uneceesary glut of OFers and DHs





Surely you're  not  serious  putting  Hicks and Ellsbury on that list. Hicks will be out for a good part of  the  year and Ellsbury isn't  even a remote possibility of playing next season. Even if he did, do you really  think he's  going to do anything having  been out 2 years and fragile  as a snowflake???




Actually I can't stop laughing at putting Andujar in right field.




Yeah, that too . Don't  have the foggiest  idea where he came up with  those gems.

4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 2:26PM #7
bumper
Posts: 6,726

Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:55PM, GottaGoToMo wrote:


Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:54PM, luvdayanks wrote:


Nov 9, 2019 -- 1:49PM, manbot wrote:


No ... unless they can get rid of Stanton ...then Yes 1 year 

  • RF - Judge /  Andujar 
  • LF - Stanton / Frazier / Wade 
  • CF - Tauchman /Hicks / Ellsbury   

DH - Stanton, Voit, Ford, Andujar


That's 8 potential OFers without Gardner why pay $7-10M when it could be used for a starting Pitcher, Betances, Romine  or anothe rBU cathcer.


There's just no room for this uneceesary glut of OFers and DHs





Surely you're  not  serious  putting  Hicks and Ellsbury on that list. Hicks will be out for a good part of  the  year and Ellsbury isn't  even a remote possibility of playing next season. Even if he did, do you really  think he's  going to do anything having  been out 2 years and fragile  as a snowflake???




Actually I can't stop laughing at putting Andujar in right field.




yup a number of knee slappers on that list Laughing


prefer to see us get younger & cheaper but no prob w gardy for more one dance at the same money if that's what they decide.




4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 3:47PM #8
chl45
Posts: 1,245

Gardner will be back. If nothing else the Yankees love him for security due to them having a walking Mash unit for outfielders. For that reason I agree. However I also know with him here it will cut down the playing time for Tauchman and that is a shame. It also leaves Frazier out almost completely so I expect to read about him having another tantrum. I will miss Maybin. Stanton more than likely will spend a lot of time Dhing, or God forbid, on the IL again.


IMO Andujar will be around because until Urschela proves he can continue to hit like he has they won't trade Andujar and IMO Andujar can't play any other position. He can hardley play the one he has been assigned. He is really a tough call coming up for the Yankees. If Gio stops hitting with consistency the job most likely goes back to Miggy. ST is going to be a blood bath come cut time. No pun intended.Wink

you miss 100% of the shots you don't take.
4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 4:10PM #9
GottaGoToMo
Posts: 77,711

Nov 9, 2019 -- 3:47PM, chl45 wrote:


Gardner will be back. If nothing else the Yankees love him for security due to them having a walking Mash unit for outfielders. For that reason I agree. However I also know with him here it will cut down the playing time for Tauchman and that is a shame. It also leaves Frazier out almost completely so I expect to read about him having another tantrum. I will miss Maybin. Stanton more than likely will spend a lot of time Dhing, or God forbid, on the IL again.


IMO Andujar will be around because until Urschela proves he can continue to hit like he has they won't trade Andujar and IMO Andujar can't play any other position. He can hardley play the one he has been assigned. He is really a tough call coming up for the Yankees. If Gio stops hitting with consistency the job most likely goes back to Miggy. ST is going to be a blood bath come cut time. No pun intended.Wink





Tauchman is Mickey Mantle apparently ... the way you are always acting as if he is worth so much.

4 weeks ago  ::  Nov 09, 2019 - 4:29PM #10
newinn
Posts: 34,031

I would rather the Yanks not bring back Gardner

Page 1 of 8  •  1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 8 Next
Jump Menu:
 
    Viewing this thread :: 0 registered and 1 guest
    No registered users viewing

Yankees Forum