Granderson is not bad at all. Yes he strikes out a lot but he does give us power and speed.
He's hit 84 homeruns in 2 years. He stays. We need that power (.916 OPS / .811 OPS)
Ichiro hit .322 while with the Yankees. Yes he is old but he lengthens the lineup like Johnny Damon used to.
Ichiro's homerun totals also increased playing in Yankee stadium and he can hit anywhere in the lineup without complaint PLUS he is capable of laying down a bunt, stealing bases, and manufacturing runs via small play.
He also is a phenomenal defender and over the course of the season, you need that. Not to mention he is one of the most humble and well respected players in baseball who is desperately seeking a WS ring before his career is over.
If the Yankees bring back Ichiro and roll with Gardner, Granderson, Suzuki they will be fine and can win many ball games because of run prevention and defensive metrics alone not to mention the speed and average dynamic those 3 will bring to the lineup day in and day out.
Ichiro was revitalized in NY. I personally loved watching him play.
All the Yankees would need to do is acquire a right handed hitter of some sort because Ichi, Gardy, and Grandy are all left handed.